Knowledge/Fault finding/Soft water can be too pure for the cooler's probes
Soft water can be too pure for the cooler's probes
FC02, or an LED that stays lit, on a cooler that has water in it can mean the water's too pure to sense. Seeley says a lit LED with the probes in water means salinity under 20 µS/cm (microsiemens per centimetre). Rainwater at the low end of its range can drop that far. Melbourne's average mains water sits above it.
- Melbourne mains
- 55 mg/Ldissolved solids (TDS), City West Water mean
- Adelaide mains
- 350 mg/Lmetropolitan mean
- Probes stop sensing
- Under 20 µS/cmwater too pure
- Rainwater
- As low as 2 mg/L35-tank survey 9 to 160, mean 33.1
Wrong
for
Melbourne
Melbourne water is soft, not hard
Almost every page on the internet about evaporative cooler water tells you to worry about scale and hard water. For metropolitan Melbourne that's backwards.
The Commonwealth's own technical research gives average total dissolved solids (TDS, the salt and minerals in the water) of 350 mg/L in metropolitan Adelaide, 114.5 mg/L in Sydney, and 55 mg/L for Melbourne's inner and western suburbs. Melbourne mains water is roughly one sixth the salinity of Adelaide's.
So scaling and dumping happen much less here. Frequent dumping on Melbourne mains is a symptom, not normal operation. If a customer says their cooler dumps constantly, investigate it rather than explaining it away.
Why would a cooler say there's no water in a full tank?
The probes find water by passing a tiny current through it. Water with almost no salt in it barely carries a current, so the probes can miss it altogether.
Seeley's own diagnostic spells it out. If the LED stays lit while the probes are sitting in water, they're reading less than 20 µS/cm. In Seeley's words, the water has very little salt content.
Seeley's FC02 cause list says it outright, too. "Water too pure for the probes to sense water is present."
That gives you a cooler reporting no water while it sits in a full tank, with nothing wrong with it. Almost nobody writes about it.
How soft does the water have to be?
Softer than Melbourne mains on average. Using the rough conversion in the table further down, the 55 mg/L mains average and the 33.1 mg/L rainwater average both work out well above 20 µS/cm. It's rainwater at the bottom of its range, down towards 2 mg/L, that sits under it.
So on a rainwater supply, suspect it early. On mains, treat it as something to rule out rather than the first answer.
How do you tell pure water from a real fault on site?
- Look in the tankIf there's water at the right level and the controller says there isn't, you're already most of the way there. On a Breezair, the level is set 5 mm above the float valve base.
- Check what's feeding itA rainwater tank pushes you toward the too-pure explanation. Inner and western suburbs mains is soft enough to keep it on the list. Bore water pushes you the other way entirely.
- Then rule out slow fillFC02 means water not detected within 20 minutes, so low supply pressure throws the same code for a completely different reason. The minimum is 100 kPa.
- Clean the probes anywayA coated probe and pure water give the same result, and one of the two is free to rule out.
Which water supply suits an evaporative cooler best?
Rainwater, and the Commonwealth research says so plainly. Its dissolved solids can be as low as 2 mg/L. A survey of 35 tanks found 9 to 160 mg/L, with a mean of 33.1 mg/L. It cools better and needs less dumping, and the research recommends it for evaporative coolers where you've got it. The catch is the one above. The purer it is, the more likely the probes can't see it.
Hard water in Victoria is a regional and bore water story, not a metro one. On bore water, Seeley switches the salinity circuit off altogether and drains on a timer instead. That shows you how different bore water is.
| Supply | Typical TDS | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Rainwater | As low as 2 mg/L. Survey of 35 tanks 9 to 160 mg/L, mean 33.1 | Best cooling, least dumping, most likely to be too pure for the probes |
| Melbourne mains, inner and west | 55 mg/L | Soft. Low scale, low dumping. Averages above the probe limit, but worth ruling out |
| Sydney mains | 114.5 mg/L | For comparison |
| Adelaide mains | 350 mg/L | The kind of water the hard water advice suits |
| Victorian bore water | Varies, often high | Salinity circuit disabled, timed drain instead |
What bleed and dump rates should you expect?
- Constant bleed is adjustable from 2 to 45 L/hr. Most residential installations sit at 3 to 5 L/hr.
- Some manufacturers ask for at least 10 L/hr, even where water quality is good.
- Seeley WaterManager opens the drain and lets out about 6 to 8 litres.
- On bore water the salinity circuit is disabled, and 6 to 8 litres drains every 65 minutes of running.
- Sump capacity on top and down discharge single fan units is 10 to 12 litres.
If the customer asks about water use, evaporation alone on a Melbourne design day at full fan speed is 58.6 L/hr for a unit moving 9,360 m³/h, and 101.4 L/hr for one moving 16,200 m³/h. At average half speed, roughly halve those figures. Across a year, whole house evaporative use works out at 2 to 10 per cent of a typical Australian household's water use.
Had a fault that didn't make sense?
The ones worth talking about are the ones where the code pointed one way and the cause turned out to be somewhere else entirely.
Send it through. If enough people have hit the same thing it becomes a page.
Who this is for: small and medium HVAC contractors in Victoria. If you're a homeowner after a rebate or a repair, you need a licensed contractor, not us, and yours can point you the right way.
Related
- How to read a fault code before you look it upAlmost nobody explains how a code is displayed, only what it means. Here's how to bring the code up on each brand, which is the bit that stalls you on site.
- Daikin fault codes: how they're built, and where to look them up107 codes in a grid, a letter for the part of the system and a digit for the detail. How to read it, and the seven meanings we could confirm.
- Which brands publish their fault codes, and which don'tSome manufacturers put the whole service library online with no login. Others publish nothing you can actually open. That changes how long a fault takes.
- Reading Braemar ICS fault codes off the board LEDsGreen flashes count tens, red flashes count ones. Plus the three lockout levels, the service PIN, and the order of checks that finds the real cause.
Review date: 1 April 2027. Figures in this area change without much notice and this page carries some that will go stale. Every number above is dated and sourced so you can check it yourself. If you find something out of date here, tell us and we will fix it.
